Huh, seems like a new music board has emerged while we weren't looking
I'm not easily given to reversing our decisions just because somebody else has a different view. Sounds a bit undemocratic but I fear we would be arguing a lot about everything then. This is why I put in the rules that decisions cannot be appealed. Pretty dictatorial, eh ? Those who don't like this are free to volunteer as an admin (if you can't beat'em, join'em, hehehe)
In this particular case I don't see that we really made a decision, we just accepted it (as with David's previous golden oldie) as something not for the site. Listening to the cleaned up version I don't find the sound quality too bad either. The out-of-tune and wobbly treble is irritating but that happens in more recordings and it's not so bad as to spoill it. So I see no reason not to put this one up, especially if the obnoxious page turns have been removed. I'll do it over the weekend.
This certainly doesn't mean we are going soft on this now. If we (Monica and I) agreed something will not go on the site, then that's it.