Mozart's Piano Sonata in C, K330

Discuss piano and other musical repertoire.

Moderators: pianolady, techneut, robert

Posts: 1278
Joined: Thu Jul 13, 2006 12:34 pm

Mozart's Piano Sonata in C, K330

Postby PJF » Tue Sep 12, 2006 1:41 am

Ironically, out of my current work list, I find the Mozart Sonata K330 to be the most difficult. The phrasing is a nightmare, and technically speaking, it is a lot harder than it sounds, IMO. It's a deceptive little devil! :twisted:

Has anyone else encountered difficulties in this seemingly simple piece?

Site Admin
Posts: 1842
Joined: Wed Jun 07, 2006 6:27 pm
Location: Sweden

Postby robert » Tue Sep 12, 2006 3:13 am

Mozart is always difficult as I want his compositions to sound crystal clear and sound like it they are played with ease. This is not easy to achieve at all, no matter technical level of the piece.

Site Admin
Posts: 8676
Joined: Wed Jun 14, 2006 12:38 pm

Postby pianolady » Tue Sep 12, 2006 11:04 am

Yes, PJF, I'm working on this too. You're right, it's not as easy as it looks. My troubles begin on the second measure. The trill. I can't get it even enough, and I think it's because I'm not sure about the execution. I have two version that show it differently. On one, it's just a trill, back and forth between I think the upper starting note (D to C) and then right to the 32nd notes. One the other version, it shows the trill connected to...I forgot what it's called...but it sounds like a turn. Like this: d-c-d-c-d-c-b-c-d-e-g. Both ways trip me up when I play up to tempo. The rest is going all right.

How does everyone else play these trills?

Posts: 170
Joined: Wed Jun 14, 2006 4:29 pm

Postby lol_nl » Tue Sep 12, 2006 3:20 pm

Mozart is always difficult to play. I have never heard any recording of Mozart I'm satisfied with. If you play it like Pires, crystal clear, it comes close, but sometimes it's just endless clear passages and you have to sacrifice some other nice things like a chopinesque cantabile like playing which suits Mozart too I think. If you play it like Horowitz, it's completely different. I personally don't really like his way of playing Mozart. It's too romantic. I wish there was something in between, but most recordings I've heard go in one of those categories. The only recording that comes quite close to what I like is Lang Lang's, but that one misses the color in his playing, so passages tend to sound exactly the same, which is again.. boring.

A tip: listen to Glenn Gould's performance :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: !!!!!

"Without music, life would be a mistake."
Friedrich Nietzsche

Posts: 1278
Joined: Thu Jul 13, 2006 12:34 pm

Postby PJF » Tue Sep 12, 2006 9:41 pm

pianolady wrote:Yes, PJF, I'm working on this too. You're right, it's not as easy as it looks. My troubles begin on the second measure. The trill. I can't get it even enough...

...How does everyone else play these trills?

Please, call me Pete. (I need to edit my signature.)

The trills:

The short answer is, play them with perfect alignment with the bass, as simply as possible within the constraints of tempo and the individual pianist, starting on the upper note, unless otherwise indicated. The more complete answer is, according to the Nathan Broder Edition (which I trust implicitly):

"The trills always begin on the upper auxiliary note, except when that note, in an appoggiatura, precedes the main note. The speed of the trill must be determined by the exigencies of each situation and the taste of the player. Where no after-turn is written out, the performer may play one or not. Where the after-turn is written out, it must of course be played. In rapid passages, where a normal trill is impossible because of tempo, a short trill or an inverted mordent may be used: eg, K330 Allegro Moderato, m. 129."

It is of great importance to understand the stylistic idiosynchracies of this sonata, et al. The sonata K330 (also K283, K332, K333, K545 and K570 ) is in "galant style (a style of "graceful elegance")." Mozart was most notably influenced by J. C. Bach's compositional style.

I found these two articles helpful.

"In music, Galant was a term referring to a style, principally occurring in the third quarter of the 18th century, which featured a return to classical simplicity after the complexity of the late Baroque era. This meant (in some implementations) simpler music, with less ornamentation, decreased use of polyphony (with increased importance on the melody), musical phrases of regular length, a reduced harmonic vocabulary (principally emphasizing tonic and dominant), and a less important bass line. It was, in many ways, a reaction against the showy Baroque style. Probably the most famous composer in the Galant style was Johann Stamitz.

Movement toward the preponderance of a homophonic texture in music had begun more than two centuries earlier, when composers started to insert sustained passages of homophony in their masses and motets to underline important portions of the text. It proceeded through the 16th century with the development of such generally homophonic vocal genres as the frottola and villanella in Italy, which led to monody and opera, the air de cour, air a boire and other continuo-accompanied songs in France, and the English lute song. Homophony grew popular during these years in instrumental music as well. Composed instrumental music seems to have consisted almost exclusively of transcribed chansons and other vocal works, or else the mere playing of such on instruments rather than singing them, until fairly late in the 15th century. In addition to this, however, existed a tradition of improvised dance-accompaniment music, and what early surviving instrument-specific compositions that are not of liturgical function follow in that vein. Indeed, a gulf between liturgical and non-liturgical instrumental music soon grew which was similar to that between the two vocal categories, though this was manifested more in form than texture.

During the 17th century, local schools of keyboard, plucked-instrument, and ensemble styles arose in France, England, and Italy, while the Germans tended to take stylistic elements from various sources. The stratification of melody and accompaniment that had been developing in vocal music also greatly influenced the instrumental; the two treble-plus-basso continuo texture of the Corellian trio sonata late in the century, for example, clearly derives from that of the earlier Monteverdian "concerto" for a few voices and continuo. It was in these local schools that emerged and congealed the characteristics called "galant," a style which was fully-fledged by the 1720s, and which, it is important to note, was recognised and referred to by this name in the writings of such contemporary commentators as Johann Mattheson (an important German theorist and composer), and Johann Joachim Quantz (composer and flute pedagogue).

Composers at least some of whose work can be described as galant include François Couperin, Jean-Philippe Rameau, and Jean-Fery Rebel of France, Giovanni Battista Sammartini, Baldassare Galuppi, and Antonio Vivaldi of Italy, the three most important Bach sons, Georg Philipp Telemann, and Johann Gottlieb Graun of Germany, and in England Thomas Augustine Arne, William Boyce, and John Stanley. As can be seen, perhaps, from some of these names, the galant style existed alongside of others, such as the lingering but increasingly retrospective high Baroque in all its national forms. As can equally be seen, the galant style was a driving force leading to the incipient "classical," or "Viennese classical" style to which point some works of Sammartini, Vivaldi, and C.P.E. Bach in particular among the above-mentioned composers. The German mid-18th century style arising from and sometimes synonymous with the galant is the Empfindsamer Stil, which in part led to the tendencies often called Sturm und Drang.

Grove's Dictionary of Music...

"During his first years in London, Bach made friends with the eight-year old Mozart, who was there as part of the endless tours arranged by his father Leopold for the purpose of displaying him as a child prodigy. Many scholars judge that J. C. Bach was one of the most important influences on Mozart, who learned from him how to produce a brilliant and attractive surface texture in his music. This influence can be seen directly in the opening of Mozart’s piano sonata in B-flat (KV 315c, the Linz sonata from 1783 – 1784) which very closely resembles that of two sonatas of Bach’s which Mozart would have known; and indirectly in Bach’s attempt in an early sonata (the C minor piano sonata, Op. 5 no. 6) to more effectively combine the galant style of his day with fugal music.

Johann Christian Bach died in London on the first day of 1782. Mozart said in a letter to his father that it was "a loss to the musical world." When Mozart first met J. C. Bach as a young boy, the two were described as "inseparable" by Mozart's father. They would sit at the organ, Mozart on Johann Christian's lap, both playing music for hour upon hour. It is often said by scholars that the music of Mozart was greatly influenced by Johann Christian. This is precisely why, in later years, Mozart would embrace the elder (Johann Sebastian) Bach's music as well. Johann Christian likely influenced the young Mozart in the forms of symphony and piano concerto. The spirit and sound of the young Mozart and J. C's music is remarkably similar. At the time of Bach's death, Mozart was composing his Piano Concerto No. 12 in A Major, K. 414; the Andante second movement of this concerto has a theme close to one found in Bach's La calamità del cuori overture. It has been suggested that Mozart's slow movement was intended as a tribute to JC Bach, his music, and his importance to Mozart's own work."

Encyclopaedia Britannica, Eleventh Edition

Return to “Repertoire”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 2 guests